PGMOL Finally Breaks Silence on Thierno Barry’s Controversial Goal Against Newcastle United as Furious Fans Demand Answers

Newcastle United supporters have been left furious following their side’s controversial 1-0 defeat to Everton, with Thierno Barry’s decisive goal at St James’ Park becoming the subject of intense debate.

The Magpies suffered another disappointing result against David Moyes’ side, but it was the circumstances surrounding Everton’s winning goal that attracted the most attention after the final whistle.

Barry scored shortly after half-time, capitalising on a costly mistake from Newcastle goalkeeper Lukas Hornicek to give Everton all three points.

However, Newcastle players and supporters immediately questioned whether the goal should have been allowed to stand.

The controversy centred on an incident involving Barry and Newcastle defender Fabian Schar in the build-up, with the Magpies insisting that the Everton forward had committed a foul.

Despite a lengthy VAR review, referee John Brooks allowed the goal to stand.

What Happened Before Thierno Barry’s Goal?

Everton broke the deadlock in the 49th minute after Tyrique George’s effort slipped through Hornicek’s grasp.

Barry was perfectly positioned to capitalise, tapping the ball into an empty net to put the visitors ahead.

However, the goal was immediately followed by protests from Newcastle players, who believed Schar had been fouled by Barry moments earlier.

The incident was subsequently reviewed by VAR, with officials checking for a possible foul and offside infringement.

After the review, the decision was made to award the goal.

The decision proved decisive, as Everton held on to secure a valuable victory on Tyneside.

Matthias Jaissle Makes His Feelings Clear

Newcastle manager Matthias Jaissle was clearly unhappy with the decision to allow Barry’s goal to stand.

The German coach believed that the contact between Barry and Schar should have resulted in a free-kick.

Speaking after the game, Jaissle explained:

“In my eyes, it’s a foul, so [it should be] a disallowed goal.”

The Newcastle manager also criticised his players for failing to react quickly enough to Everton’s attacking move.

However, his frustration with the officiating decision was evident.

The defeat was particularly painful for Newcastle, who had already lost to Everton in the Carabao Cup just days earlier.

Jamie Carragher Offers a Different Opinion

While Newcastle supporters were furious with the decision, former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher offered a different perspective.

Speaking on Sky Sports, Carragher defended Barry’s actions, insisting that the Everton striker had done nothing wrong.

The pundit argued that Barry was simply using his body to gain an advantage over the defender.

Carragher said:

“That’s great centre-forward play, getting your arm across a centre-back.”

He also insisted that Barry had not committed a foul or used his elbow illegally.

His comments have added another layer to the debate, with supporters on both sides continuing to argue over whether the goal should have been allowed.

Has PGMOL Confirmed an Officiating Error?

Despite the growing controversy, there is no verified confirmation that PGMOL has admitted that Barry’s goal was incorrectly awarded.

The official decision during the match was that there had been no foul or offside infringement.

The Premier League’s explanation of the VAR check was that the contact involving Schar did not meet the threshold required for a foul.

As a result, the goal was allowed to stand.

Newcastle supporters may disagree with that assessment, but the decision remains unchanged.

Newcastle Must Now Turn Their Attention to Fulham

For Newcastle, the immediate priority will be recovering from another disappointing result.

Jaissle’s side have now suffered consecutive defeats against Everton, and the pressure is beginning to increase.

The Magpies will need to produce a much-improved performance when they travel to Fulham in their next Premier League fixture.

With supporters demanding better results and greater consistency, the Newcastle manager will be desperate to see his players respond.

However, the controversy surrounding Barry’s goal is likely to remain a major talking point among Newcastle fans for some time.

The big question now is whether Newcastle can put this disappointment behind them and return to winning ways.