Controversial VAR Audio from Sunderland vs Manchester United Revealed as Fans Demand Action Over Diallo Handball and Martinez Incident

Controversial VAR Audio from Sunderland vs Manchester United Revealed as Fans Demand Action Over Diallo Handball and Martinez Incident

Controversial VAR Audio from Sunderland vs Manchester United Revealed as Fans Demand Action Over Diallo Handball and Martinez Incident

Fresh controversy has erupted following Sunderland’s Premier League clash against Manchester United at the Stadium of Light on May 9, 2026. Leaked audio of the referee and VAR officials’ conversation has surfaced, intensifying calls from Sunderland supporters for greater transparency and accountability in officiating.

The match which ended in a goalless draw, featured two major flashpoints. In the second half, Amad Diallo appeared to handle the ball inside the penalty area during a United attack. Sunderland players appealed vigorously, but referee Stuart Attwell waved play on. VAR reviewed the incident briefly before upholding the on-field decision, ruling insufficient evidence of a deliberate handball.

Later, tension peaked when Lisandro Martinez was accused of dragging down Sunderland striker Brian Brobbey in the 18-yard box during a set-piece scramble. Replays suggested clear contact as Martinez tugged the forward’s shirt and arm, pulling him to the ground. No penalty was awarded, prompting furious protests from the home crowd.

Leaked audio captures the VAR team discussing both calls. On the Diallo incident: “Check complete – arm is close to body, not deliberate. No penalty.” For the Martinez challenge: “Contact is there but not enough for a clear foul… play on.” Attwell confirmed the decisions, stating over the tannoy that “no clear and obvious error” occurred. Critics argue the exchanges reveal rushed assessments and possible bias toward big clubs.

Sunderland fans have flooded social media, demanding PGMOL release full unedited audio and launch an independent review. “Two stonewall decisions ignored – this robs us of points,” one fan group posted. Supporters point to Martinez’s physical style and Diallo’s involvement as evidence of inconsistent VAR application, especially given Brobbey’s strong performance up front.

The result leaves Sunderland frustrated in mid-table while United push for Champions League positioning. Manager Régis Le Bris called for “consistency,” while his counterpart defended the officials. As leaks continue to expose behind-the-scenes talks, pressure mounts on the Premier League to address VAR communication and fan trust issues. Calls for a full replay or sanctions grow louder in Wearside.