Sunderland AFC Player Ratings vs Brentford: One Star Deserves 9/10 as Two Others Earn 8s in Dramatic Cup Victory

Sunderland secured their place in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals after surviving a late Brentford fightback to claim an entertaining 3–2 victory at the Stadium of Light.

The Black Cats produced a devastating attacking display in the first half, scoring three goals in a remarkable 13-minute spell to put themselves firmly in control of the contest.

However, what initially looked like a comfortable evening for Régis Le Bris’ side became increasingly tense as Brentford fought their way back into the game.

Chemsdine Talbi, Timur Tuterov and Malick Fofana found the net for Sunderland, while Callum Wilson and Igor Thiago scored for the visitors.

Despite Brentford dominating possession and applying considerable pressure, Sunderland held on to secure their progression to the next round.

But which Sunderland players impressed the most, and who struggled to make their mark? Here are our player ratings from the memorable cup encounter.

Sunderland Player Ratings vs Brentford

Goalkeeper and Defence

Melker Ellborg – 5.5/10

Ellborg produced some useful saves during the match, including an impressive intervention to deny Mamadou Sangaré in the first half.

However, there were questions over his handling of Brentford’s goals, particularly Igor Thiago’s late header, which slipped through him.

Although the goalkeeper made some important contributions, the late scare prevented him from receiving a higher rating.

Alan Browne – 6/10

Browne worked hard to fulfil his defensive responsibilities and showed commitment throughout the contest.

Sunderland’s defensive unit faced considerable pressure as Brentford attempted to overturn their deficit, requiring concentration and discipline to protect the advantage.

Kevin Danso – 7/10

Danso delivered a determined defensive performance, particularly during the closing stages when Brentford pushed desperately for an equaliser.

His ability to make important blocks and compete in physical battles helped Sunderland withstand the pressure.

Omar Alderete – 6.5/10

Alderete contributed several important defensive interventions and showed determination when Brentford threatened in dangerous areas.

However, Sunderland’s defensive organisation was tested repeatedly, and there were moments when the visitors found space to exploit.

Dayann Mathalie – 6.5/10

Mathalie worked hard down the left, combining defensive duties with occasional attacking contributions.

His movement and willingness to support the attack helped Sunderland maintain balance during a demanding contest.

Midfield

Jules Ahoka – 8/10

Ahoka delivered an impressive performance, demonstrating composure and awareness in midfield.

His involvement in Sunderland’s opening goal highlighted his ability to turn defensive possession into a dangerous attacking opportunity.

The youngster also showed maturity in his decision-making, making an important contribution to the team’s overall performance.

Habib Diarra – 5.5/10

Diarra found it difficult to impose himself on proceedings before being withdrawn at half-time.

Although he was unable to produce his best performance, the minutes could prove valuable as he continues to regain match sharpness.

Attack

Jocelin Ta Bi – 9/10

Ta Bi was arguably Sunderland’s most influential attacking player on the night.

The winger played a decisive role in all three first-half goals, providing the creativity and attacking quality that helped the Black Cats establish a commanding advantage.

His contribution to the second goal was particularly impressive, as he beat his opponent before delivering an inviting ball for Tuterov to finish.

He then produced another excellent delivery for Fofana’s header, demonstrating his ability to create opportunities from wide areas.

With his pace, movement and creativity causing Brentford persistent problems, Ta Bi delivered the kind of performance that will excite Sunderland supporters.

Chemsdine Talbi – 8/10

Talbi played an important role in Sunderland’s attacking display, helping the home side exploit Brentford’s defensive weaknesses.

He opened the scoring in the 26th minute, finishing from close range after Ta Bi’s effort had been saved.

His movement and pressing also helped Sunderland create dangerous situations, making him an important part of the team’s attacking performance.

Malick Fofana – 8/10

Fofana capped an encouraging performance by scoring Sunderland’s third goal.

The winger found space at the back post and connected with Ta Bi’s cross to send a powerful header into the net.

His goal gave Sunderland a seemingly comfortable three-goal cushion, although Brentford’s late response ensured the hosts had to work hard to secure victory.

Timur Tuterov – 7.5/10

Tuterov took his opportunity with an excellent finish for Sunderland’s second goal.

The young forward showed composure when presented with the chance, giving his side a crucial advantage during a decisive period of the match.

His performance will provide encouragement as he continues to compete for opportunities in Le Bris’ squad.

Sunderland’s Late Defensive Test

Despite Sunderland’s excellent first-half performance, the closing stages provided a reminder that matches at this level are rarely straightforward.

Brentford responded before the interval through Callum Wilson and continued searching for another goal after the restart.

Their persistence eventually paid off when Igor Thiago headed home in stoppage time, setting up a tense conclusion.

Sunderland nevertheless managed to protect their lead and book their place in the quarter-finals.

The victory will be particularly encouraging for Le Bris, who made significant changes to his starting line-up but still watched his team produce enough quality to eliminate Premier League opposition.

Sunderland Fans Will Be Delighted With Ta Bi

While several Sunderland players deserve credit for their contributions, Ta Bi’s creativity stands out as one of the biggest positives from the evening.

His involvement in all three goals demonstrated the attacking threat he can offer when given the opportunity to impress.

Talbi and Fofana also made important contributions, while Tuterov showed why he could become a useful option in attack.

However, Sunderland will need to address the defensive lapses that allowed Brentford back into the contest.

The Black Cats ultimately got the job done, but their late struggles will provide Le Bris with areas to examine before their next fixture.

For Sunderland supporters, though, the immediate priority is celebrating a cup victory that takes them one step closer to a place in the semi-finals.